My Reviews (4 reviews)

My Reviews (4 reviews)

Cartoon Comments:


Porky and Sylvester at their best! 5 out of 5 stars

...a yellow dog of a cowardly cat!

Reviewed by: GKBowood, July 19, 2013

This is the original that Claws for Alarm was based on. This version has funnier lines and Porky is more sympathetic to Sylvester's plight in this one. This one seems to come up more often than Claws for Alarm, but they are both great!
0 of 3 people found this review helpful
Was this review helpful to you?

Scaredy Cat 6 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: damfine, October 07, 2004

This is certainly not the first pairing of Porky and Sylvester. That distinction goes to Kitty Kornered. What does make this cartoon great is that Sylvester gets to stretch his pantomime skills. Under Jones competant guidance, we get to see Sylvester try to warn Porky of their impending doom through a series of "histrionic" jestures and complex facial expressions and tell the story way better than anyone else could with dialogue (one of Jones' specialties). Another great aspect of this cartoon is that the constuction is that of the best suspenseful drama or horror movies. The cinematography and the pace create an incrediblly cerebral atmosphere that could rival Hitchcock's best work really. All this and Sylvester's ability come together at the end to make an absolutely brilliant climax. Sylvester's expressions, the sun rise used for emphasis, and the music make for an ending that can blow anything away. Thankfully, this cartoon is available on the first wave of Looney Tunes dvds. I urge all to either buy a copy or, if you've already done so, rewatch this particular cartoon to see what I mean.
4 of 7 people found this review helpful
Was this review helpful to you?

Scaredy Cat 4 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: dingdog, December 10, 2003

Jones understood as much about Sylvester as he later would the Tom & Jerry characters: in either case, no grasp at all of their salient traits. Jones' most unforgivable sin here is robbing SYlvester of the gift of speech--this was an already-well-established character trait of the cat's...part of what makes him so funny. Why doesn't the cat just SAY TO the pig there's something behind him?!?
Worst of all is the plot resolution, where Jones (of all people) drags out two of the tiredest cliches in all cartoondom: he has Sylvester's "angel conscience" appear and tell him (with SIGNS, for God's sake) to save his master (I NEVER could connect with the notion of a humanized-animal having an animal-animal for a pet). FInally, Sylvester never having uttered a word, a mouse comes out of a cuckoo clock and utters the trite line, "Pussycats is the craziest peoples!"
1 of 9 people found this review helpful
Was this review helpful to you?

Scaredy Cat 4 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: dingdog, September 05, 2002

Jones knew about as much of what made Sylvester tick as he did later about H-B's Tom & Jerry. This isn't Sylvester--this is an impostor. And he robs the poor feline of the gift of speech!
THe worst is at the conclusion: Sylvester being rendered mute, he's visited by his "Angel" conscience, holding up signs prompting Sylvester to save his master Porky......one of the tiredest cliches in cartoondom. (That's another thing in cartoons I never could relate to--a two-legged, humanized animal having a four-legged pet animal. It's kinda redundant, isn't it?)
1 of 7 people found this review helpful
Was this review helpful to you?
> >|

Add your own Review