My Reviews (1 review)

Rail-rodents Cartoon Picture
Buy Rail-rodents on DVD


Alternate Title: Rail Rodents

Rail-rodents (Rail Rodents) (1954) - Herman and Katnip Theatrical Cartoon Series Rail-rodents

BCDB Rating: "Rail-rodents" has not yet received enough votes to be rated.
Add Your Vote Now! 2.2552
Post your Comments or Review
This page has been viewed 11 times this month, and 1089 times total.

  • Herman and Katnip Theatrical Cartoon Series
  • Distributed by: Paramount Studios
  • Cartoon Characters: Herman, Katnip.
  • Originally Released in 1954.
  • Color
  • Running Time: 7 minutes.
  • U.S.A.  U.S.A.
  • Buy This On DVD

Cartoon Comments:


Posted: August 12, 2005

Routine and forgettable

The cat and mouse theme (or, in the case of Warner Bros, cat and canary or coyote and roadrunner), in which the prey invariably outwits the predator, has been the staple of hundreds of cartoons, and repetition is inevitable. But what distinguishes the classic Tom & Jerry, Sylvester and Roadrunner cartoons and lifts them from the rut are the characterisations and, particularly in the case of the Warner’s cartoons, the sharp cynical edge which gives them a freshness which belies their age.

Herman and Katnip, by comparison, are simply dull. The animation is faultless, but the characters, both in terms of drawing and personality, are bland in the extreme.

After the first minute you are aware that you are in for a long haul and, despite the fact that a cartoon is the ultimate in fantasy, you even begin to wonder why a freight train would have a refrigerated truck (except to freeze the cat), an agricultural machinery wagon (except to chop him into pieces), a crane (except to hit him with the hook) and a cannon (except to fire him to the North pole).

All in all, routine, uninspired and forgettable.

1 of 5 people found this comment useful
Was this comment useful to you?

Add your own Review